6 Legal Claims in One Month... Here’s What You Need to Know.

Back to Top

Six sellers faced legal threats in May.
Six different homes.
Six unique problems.
One thing in common?
All six sellers were protected with Home Sale Legal Protection.

Legal claims after a home sale are more common than most people think—and they’re becoming more severe. From flooded homes and moldy furnaces to undisclosed pool leaks and seven-figure demand letters, these real-life cases show how quickly things can go sideways… even months after a sale. Whether you’re a seller, real estate agent, or broker, these stories are a reminder that post-sale liability is real.

Here’s what happened—and why it matters to every agent, broker, and seller.

Real Claims From May

Dublin, TX – $1,040,113 Demand Letter

  • Months After Closing: 4.5 months 
  • Allegations: Substantial defects across multiple systems—roof, HVAC, electrical, plumbing, solar panels, interior and exterior walls, and showers
  • Buyer demand: Over $1 million

Rosebud, TX – Lawsuit Filed

  • Years After Closing: 2 years and 12 days 
  • Allegations: Flooded home, plus buyers allege that several items regarding the property were not included or explained in the disclosure notice 
  • Escalation: Sellers received a lawsuit

Carrollton, TX – $8,197 in Demands

  • Months After Closing: 4.5 months 
  • Allegations: Repair costs for roof, closet, pest control, and seeking reimbursement for the cost of replacing the washer, dryer, and deep freezer
  • Buyer demand: $8,197
  • Escalation: Written threat, Sellers Shield hired them an attorney that same day

Lakeway, TX – Pool Leak Leads to Legal Threat

  • Years after closing: 1 year and 9 months 
  • Allegations: A leaking spa caused unusually high water bills. Buyers claimed the seller knew about it but didn’t disclose.
  • Escalation: Verbal threat

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania – Broker & Seller Named in Legal Demand

  • Months After Closing: 4 months 
  • Allegations: Booster pump issues, hidden plumbing problems, mold under bathroom sink
  • Escalation: Demand letter named both the seller and their brokerage
  • Attorney hired: Same day

Marlin, TX – Mold in the Furnace

  • Years After Closing: 1 year and 5 months 
  • Allegations: Buyers found mold in the HVAC system
  • Escalation: Written threat

The Takeaway: What You Can Learn from These Claims

  1. Accurate Disclosure Is Not Optional.
     A rushed or incomplete Seller’s Disclosure is a legal risk—period. Even “small” mistakes can spark costly claims.

  2. Lawsuits Don’t End at Closing.
     Some of these issues didn’t arise until months after closing. Just because the deal is done doesn’t mean you’re in the clear.

  3. Legal Protection Works.
     Every seller listed above had Home Sale Legal Protection, which provided:
    • A local real estate attorney within 24 hours
    • Up to $75,000 of legal fees covered 
    • Support from start to finish 
    • Peace of mind for the seller (and agent!)

What Can You Do?

Agents & Brokers:

  • Encourage your sellers to complete disclosures using a guided tool like Sellers Shield’s Gold Standard Disclosure Process™—to reduce the chance of costly mistakes.
  • Make Home Sale Legal Protection part of every listing conversation. It protects your client and protects you from being pulled into disputes. Agents can purchase Home Sale Legal Protection as a closing gift for their home seller.

Sellers:

  • Don’t rely on memory. Use disclosure tools that prompt you to remember what’s important. Check out our disclosure checklist. 
  • Invest in Home Sale Legal Protection. It costs less than a 1-hour attorney consultation—and could save your sanity (and your savings account).

The Bottom Line

If these six claims taught us anything, it’s this: Disclose thoroughly. Consider Legal Protection. Close confidently.

Want to see how Sellers Shield works or share this with your sellers?
 👉 Learn More About Home Sale Legal Protection
👉 Get Started with the Gold Standard Disclosure Process™

 

Scott was sued for $200,000 two years after the sale of his home.

He never dreamed he would be served papers in his driveway.

Learn More
real customer receiving lawsuit in drive way.

Thank you!

for submitting your email